HELP!!! Is this a good trade??

[AndrewP]

I have both tom brady and drew brees on my fantasy team so i was trrying to trade one since both are top notch. i offered someone else

tom brady
thomas jones
jeremy crothchery

and i would be getting

eli manning
duece mcallister
javon walker

...... what do you think? good trade or no?

[majesstik1]

I love Walker's potential this year. The RBs are about equal, and you're taking a hit at QB.

Even though it looks like you're coming out a little behind on this, it's actually improving your roster.

Plus, it diversifies your team a little. You're not stuck with two Jets.

[DallasNiner]

I wouldn't take it.

You mean Jerricho Cotchery right and not Jeremy Crotchery

[imabored]

i wouldn't do that. no one knows how good Eli will be. Too many weapons for the saints with bush, colston, henderson, meacham, and johnson. and walker is pretty good. but unless you really need walker and Deuce, i wouldn't. you could wait for the season to start than when someone is really desperate for a QB you could trade for better value than now.

[majesstik1]

You mean Jerricho Cotchery right and not Jeremy Crotchery

Exactly why he should make the trade! If you can't pronounce your players names, get ones you can :laugh:

[funky-monk]

bad trade. A downgrade in every position... if your trading what you feel is apples to apples for the exact same positions, then the trade is invaluable. If you have Brady on your bench, just wait till someone NEEDs him, then bend that guy over and rape him senselessly for your QB. All you need is a few weeks for a team to get the "o my god, I'm screwed" feeling. Be patient grasshoppa......

[Ace Matherton]

I have both tom brady and drew brees on my fantasy team so i was trrying to trade one since both are top notch. i offered someone else

tom brady
thomas jones
jeremy crothchery

and i would be getting

eli manning
duece mcallister
javon walker

...... what do you think? good trade or no?



No chance, your getting a better WR and losing out on both other positions, I'd trade one of the QB's and a WR or RB for nothing short of an elite player. Hold on to both if it does not happen now, and make a deal around week 5 when the bye weeks come in and owners need immediate help.

Making your roster better is only half the goal, NOT making their roster better is the other half. Trade with owners than NEED not ones that are willing.

[Nevyn]

I have both tom brady and drew brees on my fantasy team so i was trrying to trade one since both are top notch. i offered someone else

tom brady
thomas jones
jeremy crothchery

and i would be getting

eli manning
duece mcallister
javon walker

...... what do you think? good trade or no?

You'd be giving up the better RB and the better QB, imho, for a better WR. And cothery isn't bad.

If you're going to offer the deal, I'd take the RBs out of it. If you want to improve at WR, maybe just offer Brady + a bench guy for Walker, then pick up a new backup off the waiver wire.

[AndrewP]

thanks for everyones help....i do think im going to cancel this trade....i was hoping to be getting a little more for brady.... i do really need a wr...my 3 starters are crotchery (or however u spell it), darrell jackson and calvin johnson... i think all three have potential but are shaky....but i will hold off on it until somone really needs him, like whoever drafted vince young lol

[JANiners]

Nope

[SBbound49ers]

Youre giving up Tom Brady who'll have more weapons than he can dream of for Eli? No way. Eli has looked decent in the past but alot of that had to do with having Tiki.