Madden YOU rate the players

[Rexi]

i saw this on another board and i thought it would be fun to do here

its simple, rate the above posters player, with the overall you think he will have in Madden 07, then post another player. I'll start

randy moss 98

steve smith?

[The Executioner]

VD 84

Terrell Owens

[Rexi]

VD 84

Terrell Owens
99

larry johnson

[iheartniners]

larry johnson- 96

eli manning

[Myrmidon73]

eli manning

87

Larry Fitzgerald

[Benji]

87

Larry Fitzgerald

91

Troy Polamalu?

[Benji]

96

Alex Smith?

80

Ty Law?

[majesstik1]

92

Brian Urlacher?

94

Steve McNair

[Nikko]

80
:laugh: :nonono:


Steve McNair

89

[majesstik1]

nikko, you're supposed to add a player to be rated, as well.

[Nikko]

nikko, you're supposed to add a player to be rated, as well.

Sorry, I was just editing it :laugh:

Reggie Bush

[majesstik1]

Sorry, I was just editing it :laugh:

Reggie Bush

I was going to post him next...

84

Duante Culpepper

[majesstik1]

Ray Lewis

95

Mario Williams

[iheartniners]

84

Jay Cutler

82

Ed Reed

[majesstik1]

Sean Taylor

91

DeShaun Foster

[majesstik1]

DeAngelo Williams

81

Donte Stallworth

[majesstik1]

D'Brickashaw Ferguson

84

Willie Parker

[Nikko]

Joseph Addai

81

Brodrick Bunkley

[The Executioner]

82

D'Qwell Jackson

78

Frank Gore

[Dinuba49erfan]

78

Frank Gore

82

Derek Smith

[SJ_408_niner]

89

Manny Lawson
82

Vince Young.

[The Executioner]

82

Vince Young.

80

Rashaun Woods :mouthclosed:

[majesstik1]

Vince Young.

80

Chris Cooley

[majesstik1]

80

Rashaun Woods :mouthclosed:

Hey, we got the same rating.

Woods = 69

Chris Cooley = ?

[The Executioner]

Hey, we got the same rating.

Woods = 69

Chris Cooley = ?

Chris Cooley is an underrated 88. :sam:
I worry about VY's game translating to the NFL.

Tom Brady

[majesstik1]

Chris Cooley is an underrated 88. :sam:
I worry about VY's game translating to the NFL.

Tom Brady

At this stage, yes. In a few years, VY will be dominating.

Brady = 99
___________________

Larry Allen = ?

[The Jerm!]

93 for Allen

Mike Rumph
82

LaDanian Tomlinson

[Dinuba49erfan]

99

Antonio Cromartie

83

Brett Favre
I wonder if theyll give him a high rating

[majesstik1]

Willis McGahee

87

TO

[DenverNiner]

87

TO
98
Jeff George (he's on "06)

[majesstik1]

Brad Johnson

88

KoRo

[DenverNiner]

97

Brad Johnson?

87

Carson Palmer

[DenverNiner]

KoRo
87

Droughns

[majesstik1]

Spencer

Charles = 78

Chris = 80

Cody = 63

Shawntae = 83

Julian Peterson?

[fourty9er_11]

Charles = 78


Julian Peterson?

88, he had a bad last few seasons so i think that will drop his rating.

Kellen Winslow

[majesstik1]

Kellen Winslow

80

Antonio Gates

[fourty9er_11]

80

Antonio Gates

99, hes got to be better than Tony

Bob Sanders

[Pound th' Rock]

99, hes got to be better than Tony

Bob Sanders

91

Isaac Sopoaga

[majesstik1]

Isaac Sopoaga

79

Corey Dillon

[eight2eighty]

88

Santana Moss


93 or 95

Brett Farve?

[iheartniners]

93 or 95

Brett Farve?

ooo, toughie, i'd say 85 because you know he has so much under his belt and he has done a lot in his career

marcus vick-and i want stats like catching, speed, and all that!

[majesstik1]

marcus vick-and i want stats like catching, speed, and all that!

Overall = 64
Catch = 69
Speed = 84
Awareness = 43
Throwing Power = 87
Throwing Accuracy = 82
Boneheadedness= 99

---------------------------

Ron Dayne?

[Nikko]

76

Kevin Curtis

84

Freddy Keiaho

PS - It's quite amusing how some people project rookies that were selected in the 20's at 82 and 83 overall, most likely they won't go over 80, and Madden will not only underate their awareness (dropping their overall), it will underate their athleticism.

[Benji]

97

Ed hartwell

91

Michael Clayton?

[Benji]

i agree and will say

94.

Steve smith

96

Brandon Lloyd

[Benji]

96

Anquan Boldin

91

Brandon Lloyd

[Benji]

92

Marcedes Lewis

80

Brandon Lloyd

[Benji]

83

Thomas Jones

86

Leion Lett

[Benji]

86

Leion Lett

No one to answer this? :tease:

[Benji]

wow your kidding right, this is about Madden Ratings meaning players in the nfl. Lett hasn't been in the nfl in years.


whom are yo telling this? ;)

[majesstik1]

Darrent Williams

84

Ben Roethlisberger

[majesstik1]

Bobby Carpenter

79

Adalius Thomas

[majesstik1]

will shields

94 Would be higher, but age is creeping.

David Carr

[majesstik1]

Aaron Stecker

79

Khalif Barnes

[The Jerm!]

82

Meshawn

85

Antonio Bryant

[majesstik1]

Mike Adams

79

Jeremy Shockey

[Rexi]

83

Chad Pennington
77

patrick ramsey

[Rexi]

76

Kellen Winslow II
81

kellen clemens

[Rexi]

72

Jay Cutler
79

michael robinson

[majesstik1]

Brodrick Bunkley

79

Kamerion Wimbley

[iheartniners]

79

Kamerion Wimbley

81

moran norris?

[majesstik1]

moran norris

77

Philip Rivers

[majesstik1]

Adam Snyder

82

LenDale White

[Myrmidon73]

82

LenDale White

79

Eric Johnson

[majesstik1]

Eric Johnson

83, but will have a low injury rating.

Cadillac Williams

[playmaker85]

cadillac williams - 92

shawntae spencer!?

[Twilt07]

shawntae spencer!?

79
Brian Gilmore?

[Forty Nine Nerd]

79
Brian Gilmore?

70

Zach Hilton

[majesstik1]

Zach Hilton

78

Brandon Llyod

[iheartniners]

78

Brandon Llyod

77

Patrick Estes?

[Nikko]

Spencer a 79, your crazy. Spencer will be much higher, probably a 87

back to the game:


Estes 71


Larry Foote

Spencer won't go over 83 or 84. Madden does horrible ratings, and at this point, the creators of the players, all they see is, 32nd pass defense, no pro bowl, and almost a nobody to them.

Foote - 86

Mike Patterson

[majesstik1]

Mike Patterson

82

Kyle Vanden Bosch

[majesstik1]

Jeremiah Trotter

87

T.J. Houshmandzadeh

[Nikko]

87
They always underate him, but 2 straight seasons he's made hte probowl and hes no doubt one of the best run stoppers in the league and what not.. I hope they acually give him credit this year.

T.J. Houshmandzadeh

87

Josh McCown

[49erfanatic]

They always underate him, but 2 straight seasons he's made hte probowl and hes no doubt one of the best run stoppers in the league and what not.. I hope they acually give him credit this year.



87

Josh McCown

Mccown - 88

Clinton Portis??

[49erfanatic]

that's kinda high for Josh and he's quite possibly going to be the back up in Detroit too.


Clinton portis

96


Vince Young
You're right not sure what i was thinking there, probably more of an 80 overall

Vince Young 84

Lendale White

[Veritas]

LenDale White 78

Larry Allen

[Veritas]

Porter 95

Delhomme?

[Veritas]

83?

Galloway

[Veritas]

92

Andra Davis (the LB)

Ehhh...88

Beasley

[TheGame]

Ehhh...88

Beasley
90

Brandon Lloyd

[Nikko]

82

Kyle Vanden Bosch

Hard to rate.. I'll say about 86.

Jerome Harrison

[Veritas]

71

LaMont Jordan

90

Isaiah Kacyvenski (he's a local "star" from here)

[Veritas]

78

Zach Thomas

89 (on the down side)

Vince Young

[Veritas]

wow thats way too low for Zach, he will definitly be in the 90's

Young- 83

Leinart

You think so? He always is, but wasn't he like 94 last year?

I think Young will be mid to high 70's. A. Smith was 82 last year as No. 1 pick (highest Rookie rating in the game).

That said, I think they'll rate Leinart higher than Young even though he went after him.

Leinart = 80

How 'bout Bush

[majesstik1]

Bush

Lot's of repeats on that last page...most from the page before...

Anyway, Bush = 83

Kris Jenkins?

[Veritas]

Lot's of repeats on that last page...most from the page before...

94 (down from injuries, with a good season he'll be back in the high 90's tho)

Nathan Vasher

Sorry for the repeats...


As for Vasher = 94

Culpepper

[majesstik1]

Luis Castillo

84

Jamal Williams

[majesstik1]

Steve Hutchinson

95

David Garrard

[iheartniners]

95

David Garrard

good one, 85

dunta robinson

[Veritas]

good one, 85

dunta robinson

84

Ebenezer Ekuban

[Veritas]

81

John Lynch

85 (on the down side)

Adam Archuleta

[majesstik1]

Laurence Maroney

79

Billy Volek

[Veritas]

79

Billy Volek

76

Neil Rackers

[Nikko]

90

Thomas Tapeh

PS - This thread needs to die, players have been mentioned 3-5 times each.

[majesstik1]

Jason Peters

81 He played very well this year, but Madden tends to underrate the quietly solid, no publicity, play for a bad team guys. 81 may even be too much to ask for.

Jared Allen

http://img87.imageshack.us/img87/1509/allenjared24gg.jpg "Say what one more time..."