The Official Rate My Fantasy Thread

[#11&#85]

QBs: Vince Young; Matt Hassleback

HBs: LT; Ronnie Brown; Deangelo Williams; Kevin Jones; Jerious Norwood; Reubon Droughns

WRs: Marvin Harrison; Lee Evans; Santonio Holmes; Greg Jennings

TEs: Vernon Davis; Greg Olson

K: Neil Rackers

D/ST: Patriots

RATE IT out of 10

feel free to post your team

[imabored]

looks good, but i would upgrade at QB. 9.5/10

[SBbound49ers]

What? 9.5? He is pretty bad at RB too. I give him a 6.

He has LT.

[Douce]

I'm still not on the VY bandwagon, and after Harrison there's nothing. Your RBs are very solid......
7..
here's mine, let me know what u think....
1st league
Mcnabb, Leinart
Westbrook, Bush, T.Jones, Droughns
Burress, Walker, Chambers,
Shockey, Watson
Graham - K
Chicago D
---------------------
2nd league
Mcnabb, ASmith
Gore, Mcgahee, Benson, Jordan
AJohnson, Driver, Edwards, Chambers
VD
DEN D & K (elam)
**** possibly trading Benson and Chambers/Edwards for Bush or Westbrook(pending)

[Fricker 4]

Douce your team is decent i give it a 7. Westbrook is your only really solid RB. If bush gets away from mccallister it will be better but he wills till produce points. No solid backup running back. Droughns is #2 in NY and wont get the goaline touches since Jacobs is a beast of a back. Not really sure about chambers either. The rest of your team is solid. I give your 2nd team better. And would not make that trade. Maybe try to give them Jordan and Chambers but dont give up benson a #1 RB for a possible #2 or westbrook.

one of my teams not gonna post them all. Also people point how many teams your league is because that also makes it help on how good you did.

10 man League:

Drew Brees/Eli Manning
Willie Parker/Deangelo Williams/Brandon Jackson/Adrian Peterson Min
Torry Holt/TJ Housh/Anquan Boldin/Randy Moss
Heath Miller
Elam
Pats D and Broncos D

When i set it up i messed up and made it where you only start 2 WRs :/ so i am in the process of tryin to trade Brandon Jackson and Anquan Boldin for Travis Henry and Mark Clayton. and in another trade that i doubt is gonna go through, I am tryin to trade my friend who is a giants fan. Deangelo Williams and Eli Manning for Roeth and Bush.

[TheGame]

I'm still not on the VY bandwagon, and after Harrison there's nothing. Your RBs are very solid......
7..
here's mine, let me know what u think....
1st league
Mcnabb, Leinart
Westbrook, Bush, T.Jones, Droughns
Burress, Walker, Chambers,
Shockey, Watson
Graham - K
Chicago D
---------------------
2nd league
Mcnabb, ASmith
Gore, Mcgahee, Benson, Jordan
AJohnson, Driver, Edwards, Chambers
VD
DEN D & K (elam)
**** possibly trading Benson and Chambers/Edwards for Bush or Westbrook(pending)

Lee Evans is nothing?:falldownlaugh:

[Wisconsin9erfan]

I just traded Philip Rivers & Julius Jones for Frank Gore, what do you think of that trade? By the way I also have Carson Palmer and Stephen Jackson.

[FODY]

I just traded Philip Rivers & Julius Jones for Frank Gore, what do you think of that trade? By the way I also have Carson Palmer and Stephen Jackson.

I hope you used some KY and at least called the guy in the morning.

[$Ciggy Cent$]

Well..... I didn't see that there. He raised it to a 7.5.

I guess its my turn...

QB-Mcnabb,Lineart
RB-Parker,R Johnson,Edge,F Taylor,Betts
WR-Wayne,A Johnson,Moss,V Jackson, Branch
TE-VD
k-Scobee
DL-Bart scott,J Farrior,L Fletcher,EJ Henderson,
DB-Chris Hope, Kerry Rhodes.

[Wisconsin9erfan]

I hope you used some KY and at least called the guy in the morning.

lol.... so here is my whole team now.

QB: Carson Palmer
RB: Stephen Jackson, Frank Gore
WR: Steve Smith, Santana Moss, Donte Stallworth
TE: Vernon Davis
W/T: Heath Miller
W/R: Marshawn Lynch
K: Joe Nedney
Def: Chicago

On the Bench: Matt Schaub, Cadillac Williams, Dwayne Bowe, Brandon Jones, Denver

[txboi]

This is my team Im kinda weak at reciever though what you guys think?

QB Peyton Manning
WR Terrell Owens
WR Deion Branch
WR Jerry Porter
RB Travis Henry
RB Marion Barber III
TE Vernon Davis
WR Calvin Johnson
RB Jerious Norwood
TE Benjamin Watson
RB Carnell Williams
QB Philip Rivers
WR Matt Jones


K Joe Nedney

Broncos D

[Douce]

I just traded Philip Rivers & Julius Jones for Frank Gore, what do you think of that trade? By the way I also have Carson Palmer and Stephen Jackson.

I hope you used some KY and at least called the guy in the morning.

LOL!!!
You should be ashamed of yourself for taking advantage of some poor lil' boy like that.... whether you used KY or not. And definitely don't call in the morning...... once he realizes what u did to him, he'll be pretty pissed!!!!

[imabored]

I guess its my turn...

QB-Mcnabb,Lineart
RB-Parker,R Johnson,Edge,F Taylor,Betts
WR-Wayne,A Johnson,Moss,V Jackson, Branch
TE-VD
k-Scobee
DL-Bart scott,J Farrior,L Fletcher,EJ Henderson,
DB-Chris Hope, Kerry Rhodes.

good team. mcnabb is a risk but looks like he's healthy.

[imabored]

This is my team Im kinda weak at reciever though what you guys think?

QB Peyton Manning
WR Terrell Owens
WR Deion Branch
WR Jerry Porter
RB Travis Henry
RB Marion Barber III
TE Vernon Davis
WR Calvin Johnson
RB Jerious Norwood
TE Benjamin Watson
RB Carnell Williams
QB Philip Rivers
WR Matt Jones


K Joe Nedney

Broncos D

looks okay. your RBs could be good if norwood becomes as good as he's been hyped. williams might get back to his rookie form. matt jones could breakout finally and johnson is a high risk/high reward.

[txboi]

looks okay. your RBs could be good if norwood becomes as good as he's been hyped. williams might get back to his rookie form. matt jones could breakout finally and johnson is a high risk/high reward.

I was thinking of trading away Philip Rivers later on in the season to get another RB or something. What you think about that, I can pick up someone like Alex Smith since we play the Cardinals twice

[sf49ergirl85]

I drafted Brett Favre with my first pick in the first round 4 different times. That about sums up my chances LOL.

[majesstik1]

This is the team I ended up with in a 10 team, 2 player keeper, $100 buy-in league. Starting line-ups are very flexible, we start 1 QB, 1 K, and 1 DEF, then you get to fill the other 5 slots with any combination of RB/WR/TE you want (2 RBs max though), and scoring is very evenly set-up.

My keepers were Maroney and Boldin, this is my team by draft selection:

Keeper = Maroney, Laurence NEP RB
Keeper = Boldin, Anquan ARI WR
Rd1 = Harrison, Marvin IND WR
Rd2 = Holt, Torry STL WR
Rd3 = Evans, Lee BUF WR
Rd4 = Davis, Vernon SFO TE (I grabbed him early, I know, but I'm really high on him this year)
Rd5 = Jackson, Vincent SDC WR
Rd6 = Barber, Marion DAL RB
Rd7 = Peterson, Adrian MIN RB (future keeper...hopefully)
Rd8 = Taylor, Fred JAC RB
Rd9 = Kitna, Jon DET QB
Rd10 = Marshall, Brandon DEN WR
Rd11 = Scaife, Bo TEN TE
Rd12 = Jones, James GBP WR
Rd13 = Culpepper, Daunte OAK QB (I've got a good feeling about him this year for FF)
Rd14 = Raiders, Oakland OAK Def (yuck, two Raiders in a row...but all my other top 10 DEFs were gone, GB went two picks before this)
Rd15 = Scobee, Josh JAC PK


And here's the positional version:

Culpepper, Daunte OAK QB
Kitna, Jon DET QB

Barber, Marion DAL RB
Maroney, Laurence NEP RB
Peterson, Adrian MIN RB
Taylor, Fred JAC RB

Boldin, Anquan ARI WR
Evans, Lee BUF WR
Harrison, Marvin IND WR
Holt, Torry STL WR
Jackson, Vincent SDC WR
Jones, James GBP WR
Marshall, Brandon DEN WR

Davis, Vernon SFO TE
Scaife, Bo TEN TE

Scobee, Josh JAC PK

Raiders, Oakland OAK Def

I'm pretty happy with this draft. There was just no value on RBs for my picks, and having 4 top 12 (my elite tier ends at 12/Evans) is fine for my scoring system, they'll produce just as well as a 3rd tier RB (the ones available for my picks).

[#11&#85]

This is the team I ended up with in a 10 team, 2 player keeper, $100 buy-in league. Starting line-ups are very flexible, we start 1 QB, 1 K, and 1 DEF, then you get to fill the other 5 slots with any combination of RB/WR/TE you want (2 RBs max though), and scoring is very evenly set-up.

My keepers were Maroney and Boldin, this is my team by draft selection:

Keeper = Maroney, Laurence NEP RB
Keeper = Boldin, Anquan ARI WR
Rd1 = Harrison, Marvin IND WR
Rd2 = Holt, Torry STL WR
Rd3 = Evans, Lee BUF WR
Rd4 = Davis, Vernon SFO TE (I grabbed him early, I know, but I'm really high on him this year)
Rd5 = Jackson, Vincent SDC WR
Rd6 = Barber, Marion DAL RB
Rd7 = Peterson, Adrian MIN RB (future keeper...hopefully)
Rd8 = Taylor, Fred JAC RB
Rd9 = Kitna, Jon DET QB
Rd10 = Marshall, Brandon DEN WR
Rd11 = Scaife, Bo TEN TE
Rd12 = Jones, James GBP WR
Rd13 = Culpepper, Daunte OAK QB (I've got a good feeling about him this year for FF)
Rd14 = Raiders, Oakland OAK Def (yuck, two Raiders in a row...but all my other top 10 DEFs were gone, GB went two picks before this)
Rd15 = Scobee, Josh JAC PK


And here's the positional version:

Culpepper, Daunte OAK QB
Kitna, Jon DET QB

Barber, Marion DAL RB
Maroney, Laurence NEP RB
Peterson, Adrian MIN RB
Taylor, Fred JAC RB

Boldin, Anquan ARI WR
Evans, Lee BUF WR
Harrison, Marvin IND WR
Holt, Torry STL WR
Jackson, Vincent SDC WR
Jones, James GBP WR
Marshall, Brandon DEN WR

Davis, Vernon SFO TE
Scaife, Bo TEN TE

Scobee, Josh JAC PK

Raiders, Oakland OAK Def

I'm pretty happy with this draft. There was just no value on RBs for my picks, and having 4 top 12 (my elite tier ends at 12/Evans) is fine for my scoring system, they'll produce just as well as a 3rd tier RB (the ones available for my picks).

your back up rbs could go either way a 7.5

[majesstik1]

your back up rbs could go either way a 7.5

They may not even play.

My starters for week one are:

Culpepper Schaub
Maroney
Boldin
Harrison
Holt
Davis
Scobee
OAK

With the WR talent I have, there was no need for me to take RBs that didn't hold the same value as those WRs.

The only move I'll probably need to make is at QB if Pep bombs out. There are a couple of good ones available, so I can watch for a bit, then move on one.

[majesstik1]

With today's news, I had to spend $5 to dump Pep for Schaub. The season hasn't even started yet, and I've already had to spend money on roster moves. :nonono:

[The Jerm!]

With today's news, I had to spend $5 to dump Pep for Schaub. The season hasn't even started yet, and I've already had to spend money on roster moves. :nonono:

Ouch dude. 5$ to change a roster spot??

[majesstik1]

Ouch dude. 5$ to change a roster spot??

Yeah, it goes into the prize pot.

Each team puts in $100 to buy their team, and $5 for every drop/add. Team to team trades are free.

Prizes are:

$20 for the highest scoring team each week.

$50 for each division winner.

Minimum of what you spent to buy your team, and all your transaction money returned, plus a little extra if you lose the Superbowl.

The rest goes to the SB winner. Last year's winner won $815.

[Lodi49erFan]

QB’s- Marc Bulger, Matt Hasselbeck
RB’s- Frank Gore, Adrian Peterson, Travis Henry, Michael Turner
WR’s- Marvin Harrison, Larry Fitzgerald, Deion Branch, Darrell Jackson, Santonio Holmes, Devin Hester
TE- Vernon Davis
Kicker- Robbie Gould
Defense- Pittsburgh


What do you think?

[FODY]

QB’s- Marc Bulger, Matt Hasselbeck
RB’s- Frank Gore, Adrian Peterson, Travis Henry, Michael Turner
WR’s- Marvin Harrison, Larry Fitzgerald, Deion Branch, Darrell Jackson, Santonio Holmes, Devin Hester
TE- Vernon Davis
Kicker- Robbie Gould
Defense- Pittsburgh


What do you think?

Nice. How big is your league?

[Lodi49erFan]

Nice. How big is your league?

it is an 8 team league...

[txboi]

I have a question. Who do you guys think that I should start this week at reciever Matt Jones who plays against the Titans or Joey Porter who is playing against the Lions?

[Bdogg]

What do you guys think? Standard scoring except QB throwing TD's=4. Bonuss for plus 120yrd+ rec/rush, 300 yrds passing


QB Jay Cutler, Den QB
RB Joseph Addai, Ind RB
RB Thomas Jones, NYJ RB
RB/WR Marion Barber III, Dal RB
WR Steve Smith, Car WR
WR Marques Colston, NO WR
TE Randy McMichael, StL TE
K Nate Kaeding, SD K

Bench Donald Driver, GB WR
Bench Ladell Betts, Was RB
Bench Reggie Brown, Phi WR
Bench Vincent Jackson, SD WR
Bench Kevin Curtis, Phi WR
Bench Leon Washington, NYJ RB
Bench J.P. Losman, Buf QB

[49Faithful]

What do you guys think? Standard scoring except QB throwing TD's=4. Bonuss for plus 120yrd+ rec/rush, 300 yrds passing


QB Jay Cutler, Den QB
RB Joseph Addai, Ind RB
RB Thomas Jones, NYJ RB
RB/WR Marion Barber III, Dal RB
WR Steve Smith, Car WR
WR Marques Colston, NO WR
TE Randy McMichael, StL TE
K Nate Kaeding, SD K

Bench Donald Driver, GB WR
Bench Ladell Betts, Was RB
Bench Reggie Brown, Phi WR
Bench Vincent Jackson, SD WR
Bench Kevin Curtis, Phi WR
Bench Leon Washington, NYJ RB
Bench J.P. Losman, Buf QB

It sucks your going to lose.:tung:

[Bdogg]

It sucks your going to lose.:tung:

Bring it on SUCKA FU!

[NinerForLife11]

What you think?

Starters:
Peyton Manning
Julius Jones
Carnell Williams
Eddie Kennison
Marvin Harrison
Plaxico Burress
Jeremy Shockey
Steelers D/ST
David Akers

Bench:
Matt Hasselbeck
Alge Crumpler
Terry Glenn
Chris Chambers
Corey Dillion
Arnaz Battle
Joe Jurevicius

[Bdogg]

What you think?

Starters:
Peyton Manning
Julius Jones
Carnell Williams
Eddie Kennison
Marvin Harrison
Plaxico Burress
Jeremy Shockey
Steelers D/ST
David Akers

Bench:
Matt Hasselbeck
Alge Crumpler
Terry Glenn
Chris Chambers
Corey Dillion
Arnaz Battle
Joe Jurevicius

Worst Draft Vote goes to you:fishing:

[NinerForLife11]

your just jealous :dance3:

[Bdogg]

your just jealous :dance3:

Why would the best team in the league be jealous of the door mat?:fishing:

[majesstik1]

This is the team I ended up with in a 10 team, 2 player keeper, $100 buy-in league. Starting line-ups are very flexible, we start 1 QB, 1 K, and 1 DEF, then you get to fill the other 5 slots with any combination of RB/WR/TE you want (2 RBs max though), and scoring is very evenly set-up.

My keepers were Maroney and Boldin, this is my team by draft selection:

Keeper = Maroney, Laurence NEP RB
Keeper = Boldin, Anquan ARI WR
Rd1 = Harrison, Marvin IND WR
Rd2 = Holt, Torry STL WR
Rd3 = Evans, Lee BUF WR
Rd4 = Davis, Vernon SFO TE (I grabbed him early, I know, but I'm really high on him this year)
Rd5 = Jackson, Vincent SDC WR
Rd6 = Barber, Marion DAL RB
Rd7 = Peterson, Adrian MIN RB (future keeper...hopefully)
Rd8 = Taylor, Fred JAC RB
Rd9 = Kitna, Jon DET QB
Rd10 = Marshall, Brandon DEN WR
Rd11 = Scaife, Bo TEN TE
Rd12 = Jones, James GBP WR
Rd13 = Culpepper, Daunte OAK QB (I've got a good feeling about him this year for FF)
Rd14 = Raiders, Oakland OAK Def (yuck, two Raiders in a row...but all my other top 10 DEFs were gone, GB went two picks before this)
Rd15 = Scobee, Josh JAC PK


And here's the positional version:

Culpepper, Daunte OAK QB
Kitna, Jon DET QB
Schaub, Matt HOU QB

Barber, Marion DAL RB
Jacobs, Brandon NYG RB
Maroney, Laurence NEP RB
Peterson, Adrian MIN RB
Taylor, Chester MIN RB
Taylor, Fred JAC RB

Boldin, Anquan ARI WR
Evans, Lee BUF WR
Harrison, Marvin IND WR
Holt, Torry STL WR
Jackson, Vincent SDC WR
Jones, James GBP WR
Marshall, Brandon DEN WR

Davis, Vernon SFO TE
Scaife, Bo TEN TE

Scobee, Josh JAC PK

Raiders, Oakland OAK Def

I'm pretty happy with this draft. There was just no value on RBs for my picks, and having 4 top 12 (my elite tier ends at 12/Evans) is fine for my scoring system, they'll produce just as well as a 3rd tier RB (the ones available for my picks).

I traded away Fred Taylor, Torry Holt, and my 7th rounder pick in 2008 for Brandon Jacobs, Chester Taylor, and the other guy's 15th round pick in 2008. So this is the updated version, new additions in bold.

[CDavis]

kinda like my team that i drafted weds. 10 team league start 1qb 2rb 3wr 1te 1def 1k. i had the 5th pick. and just wondering what you all think?

Rd1 Gore
rd2 R. Johnson
rd3 Mcghee
rd4 j walker
rd5 driver
rd6 hasselbeck
rd7 H Ward
rd8 D Jax
rd9 J. Lewis
rd10 W. Welker
Rd11 M. Clayton
Rd12 B. Watson
rd13 Dolphins D
rd14 B Farve
rd15 G Olsen
rd16 Nugent

QB
Hasselbeck
Farve

RB
Gore
R. Johnson
McGhee
J. Lewis

WR
Walker
Driver
Ward
D. Jax
Welker
Mark Clayton

TE
Watson
Olsen

Def
Mia

K
Nugent

[Bdogg]

kinda like my team that i drafted weds. 10 team league start 1qb 2rb 3wr 1te 1def 1k. i had the 5th pick. and just wondering what you all think?

Rd1 Gore
rd2 R. Johnson
rd3 Mcghee
rd4 j walker
rd5 driver
rd6 hasselbeck
rd7 H Ward
rd8 D Jax
rd9 J. Lewis
rd10 W. Welker
Rd11 M. Clayton
Rd12 B. Watson
rd13 Dolphins D
rd14 B Farve
rd15 G Olsen
rd16 Nugent

QB
Hasselbeck
Farve

RB
Gore
R. Johnson
McGhee
J. Lewis

WR
Walker
Driver
Ward
D. Jax
Welker
Mark Clayton

TE
Watson
Olsen

Def
Mia

K
Nugent

Nice depth at RB. How did Rudi make it back to you in he second? Not a bad team at all.

[blaize]

14 team league. 26 players per team. Start 1 QB, 1 RB, 3 WR, 1 TE, 1 Flex, 1 Kicker, 2 DL, 2 DB, 2 LB.

QB:
Tom Brady
Alex Smith

RB:
Ladainian Tomlinson
Marion Barber
Brandon Jackson
Maurice Hicks
Tony Hunt
Garrett Wolfe

WR:
Terrell Owens
Donte Stallworth
Brandon Marshall
Reggie Williams
Ashley Lelie
Dwayne Jarret
Robert Meachem

TE:
Vernon Davis
Desmond Clark

K:
Joe Nedney

DE:
Gaines Adams
Derrick Burgess
Dwight Freeney

DB:
Dre Bly
Asante Samuel
Walt Harris

LB:
DJ Williams
Patrick Willis

How do I rate?