Rank NFL QBs

[Brian Jennings]

Tom Brady
Carson Palmer
Peyton Manning
Vince Young
Bulger
Drew Brees
Matt Schaub
Romo
Ben
Hasselbeck
Donovan McBlack
Favre
Kitna
Philip Rivers
Jay Cutler
Jason Campbell
Lienart
Grossman
Steve McNair
Chad Pennington
Jeff Garcia
Eli Manning
Trent Green
David Gerrard
JP Losman
Delhomme
Josh McCown
Random Browns QB
Alex Smith
Joey Harrington
Tarvaris Jackson
Whoever the hell is currently taking snaps in KC

[jmichura]

I sometimes wonder if Alex will be the next David Carr. I defended David Carr and said that his line gave him little time to throw the ball. I thought that if his line would hold up, Carr wouldn't look so bad.

I was wrong and the problem wasn't the line at all. It was Carr. And I am beginning to think that Alex will fall under that category. Who knows, maybe Carr will benefit from being a backup and revitalize his career. But I doubt that's gonna make the Texans feel any better about drafting him.

I still have faith in Alex but I have to admit that right now, he is still a bottom 10 starting QB.

While I wouldn't put Vince Young that high, I have to admit that despite not being a great passer, he finds way to get his team the win.

[Eaglesfandan]

McNabb is a bottom ten QB right now.........

[Blue Bird]

Whoever the hell is currently taking snaps in KC

:laugh:

[Blue Bird]

Alex Smith
Y.A. Tittle
:falldownlaugh:

That's like "God, Jesus, and Alex Smith... not necessarily in that order." That was good. I actually laughed out loud at that one.

[Blue Bird]

Tom Brady
Carson Palmer
Peyton Manning
Vince Young
Bulger
Drew Brees
Matt Schaub
Romo
Ben
Hasselbeck
Donovan McBlack
Favre
Kitna
Philip Rivers
Jay Cutler
Jason Campbell
Lienart
Grossman
Steve McNair
Chad Pennington
Jeff Garcia
Eli Manning
Trent Green
David Gerrard
JP Losman
Delhomme
Josh McCown
Random Browns QB
Alex Smith
Joey Harrington
Tarvaris Jackson
Whoever the hell is currently taking snaps in KC

The only ones that surprised me on this list were Vince Young and Matt Schaub. Not that they don't both have the potential but you've got them above some pretty good guys so early in their careers, particularly Schaub. I also think that Smith is better than many of the guys you've got above him.

[NortyFiner]

I would put Peyton Manning #1 over Brady and Palmer, in that order. But that's mainly because I'm a Tennessee Vols fan.

[DallasNiner]

Peyton Manning
Tom Brady
Carson Palmer
Drew Brees
Bulger
Donovan McNabb
Romo
Ben
Hasselbeck
Kitna
Matt Schaub
Favre
Jay Cutler
Philip Rivers
Jeff Garcia
Vince Young
Jason Campbell
Lienart
Chad Pennington
Eli Manning
Steve McNair
Delhomme
JP Losman
Alex Smith
Grossman
Josh McCown
David Gerrard
Derek Anderson
Damon Huard
Trent Green
Joey Harrington
Tarvaris Jackson


That's a combination of things...How good they currently are and how good their careers have been...But people like Favre and McNair are lower because of current play level even though they've had good careers.

Edit: To adjust Trent Green. He truly sucks at this point in his career.

[fabie]

Peyton Manning
Tom Brady
Carson Palmer
Drew Brees
Bulger
Donovan McNabb
Romo
Ben
Hasselbeck
Kitna
Matt Schaub
Favre
Jay Cutler
Philip Rivers
Jeff Garcia
Vince Young
Jason Campbell
Lienart
Chad Pennington
Eli Manning
Steve McNair
Trent Green
JP Losman
Delhomme
Alex Smith
Grossman
Josh McCown
David Gerrard
Derek Anderson
Damon Huard
Joey Harrington
Tarvaris Jackson


That's a combination of things...How good they currently are and how good their careers have been...But people like Favre and McNair are lower because of current play level even though they've had good careers.DELHOMME is vastly underrated...he should at least be in the top 10....

[DallasNiner]

DELHOMME is vastly underrated...he should at least be in the top 10....

Delhomme is perhaps the most inconsistent QB there is. He'll throw 4TD's one game and 4 INT the next.

[NortyFiner]

Delhomme is perhaps the most inconsistent QB there is. He'll throw 4TD's one game and 4 INT the next.

Agreed. Delhomme is at best a talented journeyman.

I think Jason Campbell should be a bit higher. He's improving noticeably, and I think has a lot of promise. Brett Favre seems to be showing some of his old self too this season.

[majesstik1]

Brady
Peyton
Palmer
Bulger
Brees
McNabb (when healthy)
Hasselbeck
Kitna
Favre
Roethlisberger
Young
Pennington
Delhomme
Rivers
rHomo
Garthia
Elisha
Smitty
Leintard
Campbell
Schaub
Cutler
McNair
Sandwich
Green
Lostman
Garrard
Huard
Culpepper
Holcomb
Greise
Batch
Boller
Anderson
J McCown
Tavaris
Grossman

[DallasNiner]

Agreed. Delhomme is at best a talented journeyman.

I think Jason Campbell should be a bit higher. He's improving noticeably, and I think has a lot of promise. Brett Favre seems to be showing some of his old self too this season.

I think Campbell will be very good. I think Cutler will be top 10 soon as well.

[majesstik1]

I think Campbell will be very good. I think Cutler will be top 10 soon as well.

That guy has made a few Aaron Brooks plays this year. He's got some work ahead of him.

[DallasNiner]

That guy has made a few Aaron Brooks plays this year. He's got some work ahead of him.

He's on what Start 8? :laugh: He's shown a lot and made mistakes...some Qb's in there first 8 starts only make mistakes *cough* Alex *cough* okay first 7 starts:laugh: .

[offtackle24]

Brady
Peyton
Palmer
Bulger
Brees
McNabb (when healthy)
Hasselbeck
Kitna
Favre
Roethlisberger
Young
Pennington
Delhomme
Rivers
rHomo
Garthia
Elisha
Smitty
Leintard
Campbell
Schaub
Cutler
McNair
Sandwich
Green
Lostman
Garrard
Huard
Culpepper
Holcomb
Greise
Batch
Boller
Anderson
J McCown
Tavaris
Grossman

this is basically my list

[majesstik1]

He's on what Start 8? :laugh: He's shown a lot and made mistakes...some Qb's in there first 8 starts only make mistakes *cough* Alex *cough* okay first 7 starts:laugh: .

I haven't been all that impressed with him in the two games I've watched him so far. He hasn't been horrible, not great either. He's got the tools to be a Brett Favre type QB, but those types of QBs can be wildly inconsistent, and make a coach's hair turn gray a lot faster.

[majesstik1]

Still not sure....Who's Sandwich

Byron

[V LordofWar V]

Tom Brady
Carson Palmer
Peyton Manning
Vince Young
Bulger
Drew Brees
Matt Schaub
Romo
Ben
Hasselbeck
Donovan McBlack
Favre
Kitna
Philip Rivers
Jay Cutler
Jason Campbell
Lienart
Grossman
Steve McNair
Chad Pennington
Jeff Garcia
Eli Manning
Trent Green
David Gerrard
JP Losman
Delhomme
Josh McCown
Random Browns QB
Alex Smith
Joey Harrington
Tarvaris Jackson
Whoever the hell is currently taking snaps in KC

i like your avatar.

[SBbound49ers]

1. Manning
2. Brady
3. Palmer
4. McNabb (if healthy)
5. Brees
6. Bulger
7. Hasselbeck
8. Favre
9. McNair
10. Rivers
11. Romo
12. Big Ben
13. Cutler
14. Vince Young
15. Schaub
16. Kitna
17. Jason Campbell
18. Eli Manning
19. David Garrard
20. Matt Lienart
21. Delhomme
22. Garcia
23. JP Losman
24. Grossman
25. Derek Anderson
26. Josh McCown
27. Pennington
28. Alex Smith
29. Damon Huard
30. Trent Green
31. Joey Harrington
32. Tavaris Jackson

[offtackle24]

1. Manning
2. Brady
3. Palmer
4. McNabb (if healthy)
5. Brees
6. Bulger
7. Hasselbeck
8. Favre
9. McNair
10. Rivers
11. Romo
12. Big Ben
13. Cutler
14. Vince Young
15. Schaub
16. Kitna
17. Jason Campbell
18. Eli Manning
19. David Garrard
20. Matt Lienart
21. Delhomme
22. Garcia
23. JP Losman
24. Grossman
25. Derek Anderson
26. Josh McCown
27. Pennington
28. Alex Smith
29. Damon Huard
30. Trent Green
31. Joey Harrington
32. Tavaris Jackson

Alex Smith>McCown

[SBbound49ers]

Alex Smith>McCown

Even though hes played in 3 "open" offenses, he's shown good poise and understanding in each system. Granted, their Qb friendly, but hes looked better than Smith.

Smith always looks confused and not sure of himself and where he wants to put the ball.

McCown doesnt hesitate to go downfield and he looks good in the pocket. Alex prefers to move around and let things breakdown before he makes his throw.

[Tangeuray]

Vick gets ignored...Im sure he will be working out in Prison soon... D.Anderson(CLE) is prolly better than Grossman too

[SBbound49ers]

Everyone in this thread has lost credibilty. Harrington is a top 5 QB.

[Hobbes2d]

1. Brady
2. Manning
3. Palmer
4. Brees
5. Bulger
6. McNabb
7. Favre
8. Ben
9. Romo
10. Hasselbeck
11. Schaub
12. Cutler
13. Kitna
14. McNair
15. Young
16. Campbell
17. Delhomme
18. Rivers
19. Matt Lienart
20. Alex Smith
21. David Garrard
22.Garcia
23. Pennington
24. E.Manning
25. Losman
26. Derek Anderson
27. Damon Huard
28. Tavaris Jackson
29. Grossman
30. Trent Green
31. Josh McCown
32. Joey Harrington

LOL Alex better then Garcia, Pennington and Eli = joke. Even Garrard is better.

[BigB_85]

Tom Brady
Carson Palmer
Peyton Manning
Vince Young
Bulger
Drew Brees
Matt Schaub
Romo
Ben
Hasselbeck
Donovan McBlack
Favre
Kitna
Philip Rivers
Jay Cutler
Jason Campbell
Lienart
Grossman
Steve McNair
Chad Pennington
Jeff Garcia
Eli Manning
Trent Green
David Gerrard
JP Losman
Delhomme
Josh McCown
Random Browns QB
Alex Smith
Joey Harrington
Tarvaris Jackson
Whoever the hell is currently taking snaps in KC

Not bad, except that Vince Young and Grossman are about 20 spots too high.

[RedskinsFan86]

DELHOMME is vastly underrated...he should at least be in the top 10.... Isn't blue the sarcastic font?

[DallasNiner]

LOL Alex better then Garcia, Pennington and Eli = joke. Even Garrard is better.

Alex is better than Garcia? :ok:

[Denver9erfan]

While I wouldn't put Vince Young that high, I have to admit that despite not being a great passer, he finds way to get his team the win.

Yeah he hands the ball of too travis henry or white/brown and watches from the sidelines as his defense makes plays... then he makes one play, gets on sportscenter and gets all the credit. We've seen this before in atlanta. Eventually defenses adjust to his style, he won't be able to pass and his team will suck.

[Rexi]

Alex is better than Garcia? :ok:

Yes.