Carson or Eli?

[majesstik1]

Tough call this week. Do I start Palmer against the Ravens defense, or an injured Eli who will probably be handing the ball off a lot today, and may come out once NY gets a comfy lead?

Opinions?

:truck:

[Fez]

Tough call this week. Do I start Palmer against the Ravens defense, or an injured Eli who will probably be handing the ball off a lot today, and may come out once NY gets a comfy lead?

Opinions?

:truck:

I don't know... really tough call there. I think I'd start Palmer as well, for the reason you mention alone. But also because... you see what the Pats did against them last week... the Ravens just couldn't shut them down, and the Pats have (had) no running game whatsoever. Cincy's running game is better than NE's and should give Palmer some room to work with.

I'm starting Palmer since my backup (Rodgers) is on bye week. My third QB (yes, I do have one) is Orton going against the Pats but well, he's Kyle Orton... and he's facing the Pats. So that's a no-no.

Back to the the dynasty league I'm benching Eli in favor of Trent Edwards, FWIW. I'm tempted to start Matt Cassel against Dallas, but geez... he has shown tihs so far. So there...

[Kilgore_Trout]

I'm between Cassel and Palmer. I'm going with Cassel.

[Fez]

I'm between Cassel and Palmer. I'm going with Cassel.

Stop giving me ideas. LOL.

[GOUTES]

Palmer for sure. I don't think Cassel can do much against Dallas. Thats a tough call though.

[Pizza]

Well you were right about Eli coming out early...but he had a helluva game regardless.